In brief

The source of sciatica may be in the lower back even when the strongest pain is in the leg.

A disc herniation, spinal narrowing or a combination of changes can irritate or compress a nerve.

The location of a disc problem and the space around the nerve matter, not just the size of a herniation.

What do you mean by radiating pain: sciatica?

Sciatica describes pain travelling into a leg when a nerve supplying that leg is irritated or compressed. When the cause is a nerve root in the lower back, the pain may be felt far from its source. Symptoms may include:

  • Pain through the buttock and into the thigh, calf, foot or toes, often on one side
  • Tingling, numbness or a change in sensation in part of the leg or foot
  • Weakness in the leg or foot when nerve function is affected

Think of the spine as a fuse box and the nerves as cables running to different rooms. A problem at the fuse box may be noticed at a lamp elsewhere in the house. Similarly, the cause may be in the back while the discomfort is mainly in the leg. There may be little back pain, or the back pain may already have settled.

The strongest symptoms can be in the leg even when the cause is in the lower back.

When should you seek urgent help?

Seek emergency care for new bladder or bowel problems, numbness around the genitals or anus, or severe or worsening weakness in both legs. New or worsening weakness in one leg also needs prompt medical assessment.

What in the back or neck can cause leg or arm pain?

Nerves leaving the lower back supply the legs. Nerves leaving the neck supply the arms. Irritation of a nerve root in the neck can therefore cause radiating arm pain; this is not called sciatica.

Two broad sources of pressure are disc material and narrowing related to bone and other surrounding tissues. These can occur separately or together. Disc-related symptoms may begin suddenly, while degenerative narrowing often develops gradually. Neither pattern alone proves the cause.

Two main sources of compression

Disc herniation

Part of the softer centre of a disc pushes through its outer ring. If it reaches a nerve, it can cause inflammation, pressure and radiating symptoms.

Bony narrowing

Wear-related bone overgrowth and changes in nearby tissues can reduce the space in the spinal canal or a nerve's exit opening.

Nerve compression from soft tissue

Soft tissue can take up space beside a nerve. Two examples are:

  • Disc herniation: a common cause of sciatica. A herniation that irritates a nerve may produce more leg pain than back pain. Its position and the space available around the nerve help determine the symptoms.
  • Facet cyst: a less common cause. A fluid-filled cyst may develop beside a small facet joint as the joint and its capsule change with wear. If the cyst presses on a nearby nerve, it can cause radiating leg pain.

Nerve compression due to bony narrowing

Wear-related narrowing may develop over years without symptoms. Symptoms depend on which space is narrowed, which nerves are affected and whether other changes add to the pressure.

Lateral recess stenosis

The lateral recess is the side of the spinal canal through which a nerve root travels. Bone overgrowth, sometimes combined with a disc problem, can reduce this space and cause sciatica on the same side.

Central spinal canal stenosis

Narrowing of the main canal can affect several nerve roots. A typical pattern is leg pain, heaviness or difficulty walking, with progressively shorter walking distances. This is called neurogenic claudication and can differ from persistent one-sided sciatica.

Foraminal stenosis

The neuroforamen is the opening through which a nerve exits the spine. Bone overgrowth can narrow this opening. Because the available space is small, a further disc bulge or local inflammation may make symptoms more noticeable.

Spondylolisthesis: a slipped vertebra

When one vertebra shifts relative to another, it can reduce the room available for nerves. This may be related to degenerative changes or a structural defect. Together with stenosis or a disc herniation, it can contribute to radiating pain or walking-related leg symptoms.

Why can a small disc herniation cause severe sciatica?

Size alone does not determine how painful a disc herniation is. A small herniation directly beside a nerve may cause substantial symptoms, while a larger one elsewhere may cause few or none.

If bony narrowing already leaves little room around a nerve, a relatively small additional herniation can increase the pressure. This can be particularly important at the nerve's exit opening. The scan finding needs to be compared with the symptoms and examination.

Can pain radiate without a pinched nerve?

Yes. Pain from a hip problem, muscles, tendons or the small facet joints in the lower back may be felt in the buttock, hip or thigh without compression of a nerve root. This is called referred pain, sometimes described as pseudo-radicular pain because it can resemble nerve-root pain.

Referred pain from facet joints often stays in the buttock or thigh and usually does not extend below the knee. It typically does not cause the sensory loss or weakness associated with an affected nerve. These are tendencies, not a reliable way to diagnose the cause on your own.

Facet-joint osteoarthritis can produce this pattern as the joint surfaces change with wear. An examination helps distinguish referred pain from sciatica and from other causes of leg symptoms.

Continue reading

Patient guide

Spinal stenosis

Radiating arm pain

Cervical disc herniation